Black-and-white photograph of Eleftherios Venizelos signing documents at a table while Allied diplomats and officials gather in a large conference room.

Greek Prime Minister Eleftherios Venizelos signs the Treaty of Sèvres on August 10, 1920. Intended to determine the Ottoman Empire's future after its defeat, the agreement would be rejected by the Turkish nationalists and ultimately superseded by the Treaty of Lausanne.

Period: 1918–1923 Region: Anatolia and the eastern Mediterranean

By Robert M. Dobo • WorldRecast.com

In November 1918, Allied warships anchored off Istanbul, bringing the consequences of defeat directly to the Ottoman capital. Their arrival announced that an empire which had survived for more than six centuries could no longer determine its own future. Its armies were exhausted, its finances were in ruins and much of its former territory had already passed into foreign hands. The Ottoman government still occupied its palaces and ministries, but its authority increasingly depended upon the decisions of its former enemies.

For people watching those ships arrive, the future was anything but certain. Some hoped cooperation with the victorious powers might preserve what remained of the empire. Others feared that the loss of its Arab provinces would be followed by the partition of Anatolia itself. Turkish, Greek, Armenian and Kurdish political movements approached the coming peace with competing expectations, each drawing upon memories of previous wars and different understandings of national self-determination.

Five years later, the Ottoman sultanate was gone. A nationalist government established in Ankara had defeated the Greek army, negotiated the withdrawal of occupying forces and secured a peace settlement substantially different from the one initially proposed by the Allies. On October 29, 1923, the Republic of Turkey was proclaimed, with Mustafa Kemal as its first president.

The transformation was remarkable. Germany, Austria and Hungary had protested the territorial settlements imposed upon them after the First World War, but none had successfully overturned its principal provisions through armed resistance. The Turkish national movement had done precisely that. Its victory demonstrated that the international order established in Paris was neither universally accepted nor necessarily enforceable.1

Yet independence did not have the same meaning for everyone living in the former Ottoman territories. The establishment of Turkish sovereignty coincided with the destruction of longstanding Christian communities, the compulsory displacement of populations and the exclusion of competing aspirations for national independence. To understand the republic's creation, it is necessary to examine both the achievement of independence and the human costs of the struggle that secured it.

An Empire Already Coming Apart

The Ottoman Empire's defeat in 1918 was the culmination of a crisis that had been developing for generations. Throughout the nineteenth century, territorial losses, nationalist revolts, financial dependency and European intervention had weakened imperial authority. Reformers attempted to modernize the army, administration and legal system, sometimes introducing ambitious constitutional changes. These efforts produced lasting institutions but could not reconcile every demand placed upon an empire whose inhabitants differed in religion, language and political allegiance.

The final decade before the armistice was particularly destructive. Italy attacked Ottoman Libya in 1911, while the Balkan Wars of 1912–1913 stripped the empire of nearly all its remaining European possessions. Muslim refugees fled violence and insecurity in the Balkans, seeking refuge in Anatolia and Istanbul. Their experiences would profoundly influence the politics of the following decade. For many families, partition was not an abstract diplomatic possibility. It meant losing homes, farms and relatives, then beginning again in unfamiliar communities.2

The First World War intensified these pressures. Ottoman armies fought across an enormous geographical area, from the Caucasus and Mesopotamia to Palestine and the Dardanelles. The successful defence of Gallipoli in 1915 became an important national memory, but victories on individual fronts could not prevent the empire's overall deterioration. By 1918, repeated campaigns had devastated its manpower, disrupted agriculture and transport, and left much of the civilian population struggling with shortages, disease and inflation.

The suffering was not distributed equally. In 1915, the Ottoman government controlled by the Committee of Union and Progress began the deportation and mass killing of Armenians. The Armenian genocide destroyed much of Anatolia's Armenian population through massacres, forced marches, starvation and systematic persecution. Survivors faced displacement, confiscation of property and the disappearance of religious, educational and commercial institutions that had existed for centuries. These atrocities preceded the Turkish independence struggle, but their demographic and economic consequences shaped the society inherited by the new state.3

The empire that reached the end of the war was therefore neither politically united nor socially intact. Its Muslim inhabitants included Turkish-, Kurdish-, Arabic- and other language-speaking communities. Armenians, Greeks, Jews and other minorities possessed their own histories and institutions. Some people continued to identify with an Ottoman political order, while others believed their future depended upon national independence. There was no universally accepted answer to what should replace the empire.

On October 30, 1918, Ottoman representatives signed the Armistice of Mudros aboard a British warship in the Aegean. The agreement ended Ottoman participation in the war, required military demobilization and granted the Allies extensive opportunities to occupy strategically important positions. It was an armistice rather than a final peace, but its provisions left the Ottoman government with few practical means of resisting Allied demands.4

British soldiers in Highland military uniforms marching in formation through a Constantinople street, photographed during the Allied occupation.

British Seaforth Highlanders march through Constantinople in 1919 during the Allied occupation. Foreign troops in the imperial capital made the Ottoman government's loss of independent authority unmistakable.

British, French and Italian forces subsequently established themselves at important locations. Their governments, however, did not share a single vision of the postwar Middle East. Britain wished to protect the eastern Mediterranean and its imperial communications. France expected influence in Syria and southern Anatolia. Italy sought territorial and commercial advantages promised during wartime diplomacy. Greece, under Prime Minister Eleftherios Venizelos, hoped to incorporate regions containing substantial Greek communities.

These ambitions were frequently contradictory. The victorious powers believed they possessed the authority to settle the Ottoman question, but they disagreed over its answer. Their inability to maintain a united position would eventually provide the Turkish nationalists with one of their greatest diplomatic advantages.

The Occupation That Changed Everything

On May 15, 1919, Greek troops landed at Smyrna, the Aegean port now known as İzmir, with Allied authorization. For Greek nationalists, the city possessed enormous cultural and historical significance. Its Greek Orthodox inhabitants maintained churches, schools, newspapers and commercial networks extending throughout the eastern Mediterranean. Venizelos regarded the occupation as an opportunity to advance the Megali Idea, the ambition to unite significant Greek populations within an enlarged Greek state.

Smyrna, however, was not exclusively Greek. Muslims, Armenians, Jews and Levantine Europeans participated in a complex commercial society whose relationships could not be separated neatly along national lines. Greek claims to the city collided with Turkish fears that the remaining Ottoman homeland was about to be divided. Violence accompanied the landing, including the killing of Turkish prisoners and civilians. The occupation quickly became a powerful symbol of the country's vulnerability.5

Greek soldiers and civilians gather in a crowded Smyrna street decorated with flags, banners and a large portrait during the Greek military arrival in May 1919.

Greek soldiers enter Smyrna on May 15, 1919, amid a welcoming crowd. The Allied-authorized occupation advanced Greek territorial ambitions but provoked fierce opposition among Ottoman Muslims, helping mobilize the Turkish nationalist movement.

Public demonstrations spread through Istanbul and Anatolia. On May 23, 1919, the novelist and journalist Halide Edib addressed a large protest gathering in Istanbul's Sultanahmet Square. Her participation illustrated that resistance was not confined to soldiers and politicians. Women organized meetings, collected supplies, circulated information and helped transform opposition to occupation into a public political cause.

Mustafa Kemal emerged as the movement's principal organizer. Born in Salonica in 1881, he belonged to a generation of Ottoman officers shaped by military reform, constitutional politics and repeated territorial losses. His reputation had been strengthened by his role in resisting the Allied landings at Gallipoli. He believed that effective resistance required something more substantial than spontaneous protest: it demanded coordinated political leadership and a disciplined military force.

On May 19, 1919, Mustafa Kemal arrived at Samsun on the Black Sea coast, officially carrying out duties assigned by the Ottoman government. He soon moved beyond those instructions, establishing contacts with provincial authorities, officers and local defence organizations. The Amasya Circular of June 1919 declared that the country's independence was endangered and that its future depended upon the determination of the nation itself.6

Group of Ottoman nationalist leaders in suits, fezzes and traditional headwear, seated and standing outdoors for a group portrait in Sivas in 1919.

Mustafa Kemal Pasha and members of the nationalist movement photographed at Sivas in September 1919. The congress helped transform scattered resistance organizations into a coordinated political movement claiming to defend the country's independence.

Congresses at Erzurum in July and August and Sivas in September brought regional resistance organizations into closer cooperation. A Representative Committee, led by Mustafa Kemal, increasingly claimed authority to speak for the national movement. Its immediate objectives were territorial integrity and political independence, rather than a fully developed republican revolution.

That distinction was important. Many participants still supported the Ottoman monarchy or regarded the sultan's position as caliph as essential to their religious identity. Others believed that the imperial government had become incapable of defending the country. By emphasizing national survival rather than immediately demanding the abolition of the dynasty, Mustafa Kemal attracted support from people who disagreed about the government's eventual form.7

The movement also had to overcome serious practical difficulties. Years of war had exhausted communities and depleted supplies. Local militia leaders did not always accept centralized command. Some regions were divided by rival political loyalties, while others feared that nationalist mobilization would bring renewed fighting.

The emerging resistance was therefore not a unified nation acting with one mind. It was a coalition being assembled under the pressure of military danger, economic hardship and political uncertainty.

Two Governments, One Country

The conflict between Istanbul and the nationalist movement became increasingly difficult to conceal. In January 1920, the final Ottoman parliament adopted the Misak-ı Millî, or National Pact, which articulated territorial and political principles associated with the national movement. Its provisions emphasized independence and the integrity of territories identified with the Ottoman Muslim population, while leaving certain contested boundaries open to other procedures.

The language reflected an important ambiguity. Many Turkish and Kurdish Muslims supported resistance to foreign occupation, but that did not necessarily mean they shared identical expectations about the political future. The National Pact allowed a broad coalition to unite against partition without resolving every question of ethnicity, regional autonomy or national identity.8

On March 16, 1920, Allied forces tightened their military occupation of Istanbul, arresting nationalist sympathizers and interfering with the remaining Ottoman institutions. Their intervention strengthened Mustafa Kemal's argument that the capital could no longer provide an independent government.

On April 23, the Grand National Assembly opened in Ankara.

The choice of Ankara was both practical and symbolic. The inland town was less vulnerable to direct Allied intervention than Istanbul and could serve as a centre for military coordination. Yet its greater significance lay in the political authority claimed by the assembly. Representatives gathered there increasingly treated national sovereignty, rather than dynastic inheritance, as the foundation of legitimate government.9

Mustafa Kemal speaking before a crowded assembly chamber filled with seated deputies wearing fezzes and other traditional headwear.

Mustafa Kemal addresses deputies of the Grand National Assembly on March 1, 1921. Established in Ankara the previous April, the assembly provided the nationalist movement with a political authority independent of the Ottoman government in occupied Istanbul.

For the next two years, two authorities claimed to represent the country. Sultan Mehmed VI and his ministers remained in Istanbul, hoping that accommodation with the Allies might preserve the monarchy. The Ankara government rejected the idea that a ruler operating under foreign occupation could determine the nation's future.

This conflict produced armed confrontations as well as constitutional arguments. Forces loyal to the sultan, regional opponents and independent militia commanders challenged Ankara's authority. The nationalist leadership responded by building a regular army and suppressing resistance to its expanding control.

The struggle demanded enormous sacrifices from civilians. Families already impoverished by successive wars were required to contribute animals, food, clothing and equipment. Agricultural labour became scarce as men returned to military service. A movement promising national independence depended upon communities that had little left to give.

Nevertheless, Ankara gradually developed the institutions required to sustain a war. Its assembly debated legislation, established administrative structures and exercised increasing authority over commanders in the field. The national movement was becoming a functioning state before its future independence had been secured.10

Sèvres: A Peace That Existed on Paper

On August 10, 1920, representatives of the Ottoman government signed the Treaty of Sèvres near Paris. The agreement embodied the victorious powers' ambitions for the defeated empire and appeared to confirm the end of Ottoman political independence on terms far more severe than many of its inhabitants had feared.

The treaty transferred eastern Thrace to Greece and provided arrangements under which Greece would administer Smyrna and its surrounding territory, while Ottoman sovereignty remained nominally recognized during a transitional period. A subsequent procedure could lead to the region's incorporation into Greece.

The treaty also recognized an independent Armenian state, with part of its frontier to be determined through arbitration by the president of the United States. Separate provisions envisaged autonomy for predominantly Kurdish areas and established conditions under which independence might eventually be considered. The Straits would fall under an international regime, while the remaining Ottoman state faced substantial military, financial and territorial restrictions.11

For Turkish nationalists, Sèvres represented the partition they were determined to prevent. It seemed to reduce the country to a dependent state surrounded by territories assigned to foreign powers or alternative national authorities.

Yet the treaty held different meanings for other populations. Armenians seeking security after genocide saw the possibility of internationally recognized statehood. Greek nationalists believed that the settlement might secure the communities and territories they wished to unite with Greece. Kurdish political activists could identify a potential pathway toward autonomy or independence, although the treaty's provisions were conditional and did not guarantee a Kurdish state.12

The central weakness of Sèvres was that the Ottoman government lacked the power to enforce it across Anatolia. The Grand National Assembly rejected the agreement, which never entered into force. Its implementation depended upon the willingness and capacity of the victorious powers to impose their settlement militarily.

That willingness was already weakening. Britain remained strongly opposed to the nationalist movement, but another extensive war in Anatolia offered few attractions to a country exhausted by the First World War. France increasingly questioned its military commitments in southern Anatolia. Italy resented Greek expansion into regions where Rome had expected influence.

Greece consequently became the principal power attempting to enforce the western Anatolian settlement. The success or failure of its army would determine whether the provisions associated with Smyrna could become political reality.

Sèvres thus exposed a fundamental contradiction in the postwar order. The victorious powers claimed the authority to decide the future of the defeated empire, but they lacked the unity required to make their decisions permanent.

The Armies That Redrew the Map

The nationalist movement fought on several fronts, each presenting different political and military challenges. In eastern Anatolia and the Caucasus, Turkish nationalist forces confronted the independent Republic of Armenia, established in 1918 amid the collapse of Russian imperial authority.

For Armenian leaders, territorial security was inseparable from the survival of communities devastated by genocide and war. International promises offered hope, but Armenia was militarily vulnerable and diplomatically isolated. In the autumn of 1920, forces under Kâzım Karabekir defeated Armenian troops, while Soviet expansion transformed the region's political situation.

The subsequent treaties of Moscow and Kars in 1921 helped establish Turkey's northeastern frontier. Soviet Russia provided Ankara with important diplomatic and material assistance, reflecting a shared interest in resisting the influence of the victorious Western powers. The two movements did not share the same ideology, but their immediate strategic interests overlapped.13

In southern Anatolia, fighting continued against French forces and their local allies. Cilicia became a particularly troubled region because Armenian survivors and returning refugees feared renewed persecution as military authority shifted. The conflict involved irregular warfare, attacks upon civilians and profound insecurity.

France eventually concluded that continued confrontation offered diminishing returns. The Ankara Agreement of October 20, 1921, provided for French withdrawal from much of the occupied territory. It strengthened the nationalist government's position and allowed Ankara to concentrate greater resources against the Greek army.

The Kurdish regions presented another challenge. Kurdish political opinion was divided. Some leaders supported the nationalist movement through shared Muslim solidarity, hostility to foreign occupation or expectations of future political recognition. Others sought autonomy or independence.

The Koçgiri rebellion of 1920–1921, centred among Kurdish Alevi communities east of Sivas, brought these differences into armed conflict. Its suppression by Ankara's forces involved severe violence and demonstrated that the nationalist leadership would not readily tolerate competing claims to sovereignty within the territory it intended to govern.14

The decisive military struggle, however, developed in western Anatolia. Greek forces advanced beyond Smyrna, hoping that battlefield success would secure the territorial settlement. Their campaign extended deep into the interior, increasing the difficulties of supply and exposing soldiers to exhaustion and resistance.

Greek politics complicated the operation. Venizelos lost the November 1920 election, while the return of King Constantine weakened Greece's relationship with some of its former Allied supporters. Britain remained sympathetic, but France and Italy became increasingly unwilling to place their policies behind Greek ambitions.

Turkish nationalist forces, meanwhile, developed into a more effective regular army. Victories associated with İsmet Pasha at İnönü in 1921 strengthened the government's confidence and demonstrated that resistance could achieve more than localized guerrilla warfare.15

The decisive test came later that year. Between August 23 and September 13, Greek and Turkish forces fought the Battle of Sakarya, west of Ankara. Greek commanders sought a victory that might destroy the nationalist army's ability to resist. Instead, their troops encountered determined opposition across a broad front.

Black-and-white archival photograph showing Greek soldiers during their withdrawal from Anatolia in the closing stages of the Greek–Turkish War.

Greek soldiers retreat during the final stages of the Asia Minor campaign in 1922. The collapse of the Greek military position ended the immediate prospect of enforcing the territorial arrangements envisaged at Sèvres.

The Greek advance failed, and the army eventually withdrew. Sakarya did not immediately end the war, but it marked a strategic turning point. Ankara had survived its greatest immediate military danger, while Mustafa Kemal's authority and reputation increased considerably.16

The human cost of the fighting was immense. Both sides committed abuses against civilians, including killings, expulsions and the destruction of settlements. Greek forces and associated irregulars devastated communities during occupation and retreat, while Turkish nationalist troops and armed groups persecuted Greek and Armenian civilians, including people far removed from the active battlefield.

These atrocities reflected more than the brutality of conventional warfare. National identity increasingly became a presumed indication of political allegiance, turning civilians into suspected enemies regardless of their individual actions.17

On August 26, 1922, the Turkish army launched its final major offensive. Greek defences collapsed near Afyonkarahisar, and the retreat toward the Aegean became a disaster. Within two weeks, nationalist forces reached Smyrna.

The military campaign had settled what diplomacy at Sèvres could not. Greece could no longer impose its claims in western Anatolia, and the victorious powers faced a nationalist government capable of defending its territorial demands.

The City That Victory Could Not Save

On September 9, 1922, Turkish nationalist troops entered Smyrna. For supporters of the independence movement, the recovery of the city represented a moment of extraordinary triumph. The Greek landing three years earlier had helped transform local opposition into a national struggle; now the army that had occupied the city was defeated.

For Smyrna's Greek and Armenian communities, however, the approaching nationalist army brought terror. Many inhabitants had already fled, while others hoped that foreign consulates and warships would provide protection. Violence followed the Turkish entry, and the Greek Orthodox metropolitan Chrysostomos was killed.

On September 13, a devastating fire spread through the city, destroying much of its Greek and Armenian districts. Refugees crowded the waterfront, seeking passage aboard ships as buildings burned behind them. Families were separated, businesses disappeared and the commercial world that had sustained Smyrna for generations was shattered.

Historical photograph showing thick smoke rising above Smyrna's waterfront and urban buildings during the September 1922 fire.

Smoke rises over Smyrna during the devastating fire of September 1922. The catastrophe destroyed much of the city's Greek and Armenian quarters and accompanied the flight of large numbers of Christian inhabitants.

Responsibility for the fire has remained bitterly contested. Greek and Armenian accounts have generally attributed it to Turkish forces, while traditional Turkish narratives have blamed Greeks or Armenians. Historians have examined conflicting testimony, eyewitness reports and the political uses of the catastrophe. The evidence has persuaded many scholars that Turkish personnel were responsible for starting or spreading fires, although aspects of the event remain disputed.18

The humanitarian consequences are not in doubt. Large numbers of Christians fled or were expelled, while the surviving population faced enormous uncertainty. The destruction of Smyrna accelerated a demographic transformation already underway through warfare, deportation and displacement.

The city would recover as İzmir, an important commercial centre of modern Turkey. Yet recovery did not mean the restoration of the society that had existed before 1919. The churches, schools, commercial networks and neighbourhoods associated with its former Christian populations had suffered losses that could not simply be reversed.19

Military victory had secured the nationalist movement's position, but the same events marked the destruction of an older eastern Mediterranean world whose communities had been connected through trade, religion, language and family relationships.

The Sultan's Last Autumn

The Greek defeat created the possibility of a confrontation between Turkish nationalist forces and the British troops still occupying strategic positions near the Straits. The resulting Chanak crisis in September 1922 briefly raised the prospect of another major war.

Britain's determination to maintain its position was not matched by its allies. France and Italy were unwilling to support a renewed military campaign, while the British government confronted serious political opposition to further fighting. Negotiations eventually produced the Armistice of Mudanya, signed on October 11, 1922, which established arrangements for the restoration of Turkish control over eastern Thrace.20

The crisis also settled an important political question. The victorious powers could no longer negotiate the future of Turkey as though the sultan's government alone represented the country. Ankara possessed military power, territorial control and an increasingly established political structure.

Mustafa Kemal was determined that the forthcoming peace conference would not restore the old division of authority.

On November 1, 1922, the Grand National Assembly abolished the Ottoman sultanate. The decision ended the political institution through which the Ottoman dynasty had governed for more than six centuries. Sultan Mehmed VI departed Istanbul aboard a British warship on November 17.

The abolition of the sultanate did not immediately eliminate the caliphate. The assembly selected Abdülmecid II as caliph, preserving the religious institution while separating it from the monarchy's former political authority. The caliphate would survive until March 1924, when the republican government abolished it as well.21

This gradual transformation reflected the political complexity of the independence movement. Many of its supporters had fought to defend what they understood as a Muslim homeland and had not necessarily intended to establish a secular republic. The leadership's commitment to national sovereignty gradually displaced dynastic authority, but it did so through a series of political decisions rather than a single revolutionary declaration.

By the end of 1922, the Ottoman monarchy had disappeared. What remained was to secure international recognition for the state that had replaced it.

Lausanne: Independence at the Negotiating Table

The peace conference at Lausanne opened on November 20, 1922. The Turkish delegation, headed by İsmet Pasha, confronted experienced Allied diplomats determined to preserve their governments' strategic and economic interests.

Black-and-white press photograph of İsmet Pasha and Turkish delegates during the 1922 Lausanne peace conference.

İsmet Pasha and members of the Turkish delegation photographed during the Lausanne negotiations in 1922. Their task was to replace the rejected Sèvres settlement with an agreement recognizing the sovereignty of the new Turkish state.

Negotiations covered territorial boundaries, the Straits, Ottoman debts, foreign commercial privileges and minority protections. The Turkish delegation insisted upon ending the capitulations, arrangements that had granted foreign nationals extensive legal and economic privileges under the Ottoman Empire.

To the nationalists, the capitulations represented more than an inconvenient commercial system. They symbolized the dependence that had increasingly undermined Ottoman sovereignty. Their removal was essential to establishing a state capable of exercising independent authority over its own territory.22

The discussions were difficult and temporarily broke down in February 1923. When negotiations resumed in April, however, neither side could ignore the altered balance of power. The Turkish nationalists had defeated the Greek army, secured eastern Thrace and established a functioning government. The Allies could negotiate terms, but enforcing Sèvres would require a military commitment they were unwilling to undertake.

On July 24, 1923, the Treaty of Lausanne was signed.

The agreement recognized Turkish sovereignty over Anatolia and eastern Thrace within the negotiated boundaries. It ended the capitulations and provided for the allocation of Ottoman financial obligations. Turkey accepted the loss of former Ottoman territories beyond its new frontiers, including the Arab provinces.

The treaty did not grant Ankara every territorial demand. The future of Mosul remained unresolved and would be decided later, through negotiations and League of Nations involvement, in favour of its inclusion in British-mandated Iraq. The Straits remained subject to international arrangements and demilitarization provisions. Turkey would secure a substantially revised regime through the Montreux Convention in 1936.23

Lausanne was therefore not the complete restoration of Ottoman power. It represented the recognition of a new national state, considerably smaller than the former empire but possessing far greater independence than the Ottoman government would have retained under Sèvres.

The treaty also contained provisions protecting minorities. Articles 37–45 established obligations concerning equality before the law, religious freedom, education and other rights, particularly for non-Muslim communities. The provisions reflected international concerns about the treatment of minorities, but they did not establish political autonomy for groups whose aspirations conflicted with Ankara's vision of the state.24

For Armenian nationalists, the territorial possibilities associated with Sèvres had disappeared. Greek claims to Smyrna and eastern Thrace had been defeated. Kurdish demands for recognized autonomy or independence received no comparable settlement.

Lausanne was celebrated in Turkey as a triumph of national sovereignty. For communities whose political futures had once appeared open, it marked the closing of possibilities that had briefly seemed attainable.

When Peace Required People to Leave

Perhaps the most far-reaching human consequence of the settlement was the compulsory population exchange between Greece and Turkey.

Its legal foundation preceded the principal peace treaty. On January 30, 1923, Greek and Turkish representatives signed a convention requiring the transfer of specified populations between their countries.

Group of displaced Greek and Armenian children standing together outside a building near Athens in 1923, wearing modest clothing and looking toward the camera.

Greek and Armenian refugee children near Athens in 1923, following their displacement from Anatolia. Their experiences reveal the human consequences of war, expulsion and the upheavals accompanying the Greek–Turkish population exchange.

The exchange was defined primarily by religion, not language or personal national identity. Greek Orthodox Turkish nationals were required to leave Turkey, while Muslim Greek nationals were required to leave Greece. Established Greek Orthodox inhabitants of Istanbul and Muslim inhabitants of western Thrace received exemptions under the convention.25

This distinction had extraordinary consequences. Not every Orthodox Christian in Anatolia spoke Greek. Turkish-speaking Orthodox communities, including the Karamanlides of central Anatolia, possessed cultural traditions shaped by generations of life within the Ottoman world. Similarly, some Muslims living in Greece spoke Greek or other languages rather than Turkish.

Under the exchange, religious affiliation determined where people were expected to belong. Families could be sent to countries whose languages, customs and local societies were unfamiliar to them.

The agreement also formalized a process of displacement that had already begun. By January 1923, enormous numbers of Greeks had fled or been expelled from Anatolia and eastern Thrace. The convention included provisions treating earlier departures as part of the population movement, meaning that the exchange cannot be understood simply by counting people transferred after its signing.

Estimates commonly identify approximately 1.2 million Orthodox Christians displaced toward Greece during the wider upheaval and somewhat fewer than 400,000 Muslims moving from Greece to Turkey. The figures vary according to the geographical and chronological boundaries used, and many Greek refugees had left before the compulsory exchange was formally implemented.26

Supporters defended the agreement as a means of preventing renewed communal violence. After years of war and displacement, many diplomats believed that attempting to restore mixed populations would prolong insecurity. The Norwegian humanitarian Fridtjof Nansen, working through the League of Nations refugee system, helped promote an internationally organized solution.

Yet this reasoning transformed displacement into an accepted instrument of international policy. Rather than demanding that governments protect all inhabitants within existing communities, the agreement treated the removal of communities as a means of achieving peace.

For those affected, the consequences reached far beyond a change of nationality.

Families abandoned homes occupied for generations, fields they had cultivated, familiar markets and burial places containing their ancestors. Property assessments and compensation procedures could assign monetary values to buildings or agricultural land, but they could not measure the meaning of an ancestral village or the loss of an entire community.

Refugees arriving in Greece faced shortages of housing, employment and agricultural land. Existing residents sometimes regarded newcomers as competitors for scarce resources, despite shared religious or national identities. In Turkey, Muslim arrivals encountered unfamiliar landscapes, administrative requirements and cultural differences. Some spoke languages that officials and neighbours did not understand.

The abandoned properties of departing populations became essential to resettlement. Houses and farms left by Orthodox Christians could be assigned to incoming Muslims, while Muslim properties in Greece became part of arrangements intended to accommodate Christian refugees. These transfers created disputes over ownership, compensation and the practical allocation of land.27

The exchange altered the cultural landscape of both countries. Anatolian towns lost churches, schools, newspapers and established commercial communities. Settlements in Greece lost mosques, Muslim religious institutions and longstanding economic relationships. Buildings were repurposed, abandoned or demolished, while new populations adapted inherited spaces to different needs.

Even exemptions did not guarantee permanent security. The Greek Orthodox population remaining in Istanbul and the Muslim community of western Thrace continued to depend upon relations between two states whose recent history had been profoundly violent.

The exchange was therefore not simply a movement of people across a border. It helped remake the relationship between national identity, religion and territory. The assumption that each country should contain a more homogeneous population became embedded in the settlement itself.

For the refugees, however, the disappearance of a former homeland did not mean the disappearance of attachment to it. Memories survived through family stories, songs, religious customs and accounts of villages left behind. Some descendants inherited the names of places they had never visited, while others grew up in homes whose previous inhabitants had undergone a similar journey in the opposite direction.28

The politicians who negotiated the exchange believed they were closing a dangerous chapter in the eastern Mediterranean's history. For the people who experienced it, the consequences extended across generations.

A Republic Built on the Ruins of an Empire

On October 13, 1923, Ankara was formally designated Turkey's capital. Sixteen days later, on October 29, the Grand National Assembly proclaimed the Republic of Turkey, and Mustafa Kemal became its first president.

Original colour autochrome portrait of Mustafa Kemal in a dark coat and fur military cap, photographed in Ankara in December 1922.

Mustafa Kemal photographed in Ankara on December 29, 1922, while serving as president of the Grand National Assembly and commander-in-chief of the nationalist army. This contemporary autochrome captures the future president of Turkey less than a year before the republic's proclamation.

The republic inherited a country devastated by prolonged warfare. Agricultural production had been disrupted, transport networks required repair and the arrival of refugees created urgent demands for housing and employment. The disappearance of large Christian populations had also transformed commercial life, property ownership and the composition of many towns.

The government faced the immediate tasks of restoring economic activity, collecting revenue and establishing effective administration. Its leaders also intended changes extending far beyond the peace settlement. Reforms in education, law, public institutions and the relationship between religion and government would eventually reshape Turkish society.

These later transformations were not inevitable consequences of victory in 1922. They emerged from political struggles within the new republic and from Mustafa Kemal's increasingly influential understanding of modernization, national identity and state authority.29

The republic represented a decisive break with the Ottoman dynasty, but it did not emerge without institutional continuity. Military officers, administrators and political ideas inherited from the empire's final decades remained influential. Many leading nationalists had themselves participated in Ottoman institutions before rejecting the sultan's authority.

There was also a tension between the inclusive language employed during the independence struggle and the increasingly centralized conception of national identity developed afterward. Turkish and Kurdish Muslims had fought together against foreign occupation, but they had not necessarily agreed upon the implications of sovereignty. The republic's subsequent policies would make this divergence more apparent.

The experience of Armenians and Greeks was different but equally central to understanding the transformation. The republic emerged in a society already reshaped by genocide, persecution, expulsion and compulsory population exchange. Its institutions developed within demographic and property arrangements created partly through the destruction or displacement of communities that had inhabited Anatolia for centuries.

The new Turkish state had defeated the partition contemplated at Sèvres. It had not restored the diverse imperial society that existed before the preceding decade of warfare.

The Borders That Outlived the War

The creation of the Turkish Republic occupies a central place in modern Turkish historical memory. The resistance to occupation, the victories at Sakarya and Smyrna, and the diplomatic settlement at Lausanne became foundational elements of the country's national story. Mustafa Kemal emerged as the figure who had transformed military defeat into political independence, and the republic's establishment offered a powerful narrative of national survival. Yet the significance of that achievement is better understood when it is placed alongside the uncertainty of the struggle itself. In 1919, neither the survival of an independent Turkish state nor the eventual boundaries of that state were assured. The outcome depended upon military organization, popular mobilization, Allied divisions and decisions taken by leaders whose alternatives remained genuinely open.

The settlement also transformed the cultural and social history of the eastern Mediterranean. Greece's military defeat ended its immediate territorial ambitions in Anatolia, but the refugee crisis reshaped Greek towns, politics and cultural life. Displaced communities carried musical traditions, religious practices, foodways and memories that became part of the receiving society. Muslim refugees arriving in Turkey brought similarly varied customs and experiences, reflecting the diversity of the communities they had left behind. The population exchange did not instantly create culturally uniform nations. Instead, it produced societies whose inhabitants were often struggling to reconcile official expectations of national belonging with complex personal histories. The lasting cultural influence of displacement demonstrates that borders can change more quickly than identities, memories or attachments to place.30

The Turkish victory also holds significance within the wider history of empire and self-determination. The nationalist movement demonstrated that the territorial decisions of the victorious powers could be overturned when those powers lacked the unity or determination to enforce them. Its success attracted attention among movements elsewhere that opposed imperial domination and sought greater political independence. Nevertheless, the Turkish example exposed the contradictions inherent in the postwar language of national liberation. Ankara successfully defended its sovereignty against foreign interference while rejecting competing national aspirations within the territory it claimed. The autonomy sought by some Kurdish leaders, the territorial security demanded by Armenians and the national ambitions of Greeks were not resolved through a universal application of self-determination. They were settled through war, diplomacy and the unequal distribution of political power.

Historical scholarship has increasingly examined these contradictions by placing the experiences of civilians, minorities and refugees alongside the military and political achievements of the nationalist leadership. The Armenian genocide, the Greek–Turkish War, the suppression of Kurdish opposition and the compulsory population exchange are now studied as connected elements of the broader transformation from empire to nation-state. This does not diminish the importance of Turkey's recovery of independence. It establishes that the recovery occurred within a violent process of demographic and political change whose consequences cannot be understood through the language of victory alone. Nor were the experiences of ordinary people confined to the decisions of statesmen. Families rebuilt lives, preserved traditions and passed memories of loss to later generations, ensuring that the disappearance of old communities did not entirely erase their presence from the historical record.31

The most enduring significance of the years between 1918 and 1923 lies in the relationship between achievement and loss. Turkey emerged from imperial defeat as an internationally recognized republic, having compelled the victorious powers to abandon much of their original settlement. Its success changed the balance of power in the eastern Mediterranean and helped establish the foundations of a state that would remain a significant regional actor. But the same transformation left unsettled questions of belonging, historical responsibility and national identity. For many Turkish families, these years represented resistance and survival; for Greek and Armenian families, the destruction of communities and ancestral homes; for Kurdish nationalists, the narrowing of opportunities for self-government. These histories are not interchangeable, but neither can they be separated entirely. Together, they explain why the passage from sultan to republic was not simply the replacement of one government by another. It was one of the most consequential and contested remakings of the world that emerged from the First World War.


Sources and Further Reading

Books and Scholarly Studies

Ahmad, Feroz. The Making of Modern Turkey. Routledge, 1993.

Gingeras, Ryan. Sorrowful Shores: Violence, Ethnicity, and the End of the Ottoman Empire, 1912–1923. Oxford University Press, 2009.

Hirschon, Renée, ed. Crossing the Aegean: An Appraisal of the 1923 Compulsory Population Exchange between Greece and Turkey. Berghahn Books, 2003. Publisher.

Kolluoğlu Kırlı, Biray. “Forgetting the Smyrna Fire.” History Workshop Journal 60, no. 1 (2005): 25–44. Oxford Academic.

Llewellyn Smith, Michael. Ionian Vision: Greece in Asia Minor, 1919–1922. St. Martin's Press, 1973.

Massicard, Elise. “The Repression of the Koçgiri Rebellion, 1920–1921.” Online Encyclopedia of Mass Violence, September 28, 2009. Sciences Po.

Tusan, Michelle. Smyrna's Ashes: Humanitarianism, Genocide, and the Birth of the Middle East. University of California Press, 2012. Publisher.

Üngör, Uğur Ümit. The Making of Modern Turkey: Nation and State in Eastern Anatolia, 1913–1950. Oxford University Press, 2011.

Zürcher, Erik Jan. Turkey: A Modern History. 3rd ed., I.B. Tauris, 2004.

Primary Documents and Historical Institutions

Treaty of Peace Between the Allied and Associated Powers and Turkey. Signed at Sèvres, August 10, 1920. Qatar Digital Library.

Treaty of Peace with Turkey. Signed at Lausanne, July 24, 1923. Republic of Türkiye Ministry of Foreign Affairs.

Convention Concerning the Exchange of Greek and Turkish Populations. Signed at Lausanne, January 30, 1923. Official treaty text.

United States Department of State. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1920, volume III. Documentation concerning the arbitration of the Turkish–Armenian frontier. Office of the Historian.

United States Holocaust Memorial Museum. “The Armenian Genocide (1915–16): Overview.” Holocaust Encyclopedia.

New Zealand Ministry for Culture and Heritage. “Birth of the Turkish Republic.” NZHistory.